Review: A book that solves the mystery of Davy Crockett’s demise

The Alamo has long been a symbol of courage, sacrifice, and myth-making in American history. In a new book that revisits the fateful events of 1836, the authors apply modern cold case methodology to separate fact from folklore, focusing on one of the Alamo’s most enduring figures: Davy Crockett.

Using techniques borrowed from forensic investigations, the book, David Crockett Went Down Fighting: How We Know It, meticulously examines eyewitness accounts to determine how Crockett met his end. Was he killed in battle, or was he captured and executed after the fort fell? The authors, Phil Guarnieri and Richard L. Range, weigh conflicting testimony with scientific rigor, making a compelling case that challenges traditional narratives.

In a compelling exploration of Davy Crockett’s last moments, the authors provide a nuanced and respectful analysis of the various theories surrounding his fate. They begin by briefly introducing Crockett, assuming readers have some prior knowledge of his story, before diving into the longstanding controversy that emerged shortly after the Battle of the Alamo.

The authors meticulously examine newspaper articles and letters, showing how these documents influenced each other over time. I found this part so detailed that I almost needed a color chart to track references, that’s how deeply the book delves into the mystery of Crockett’s death.

The book also tackles the large number of accounts that claim Crockett was captured and executed. Many of these accounts come from unknown sources, which affects their credibility. The authors weigh these accounts carefully, emphasizing that sheer volume does not necessarily equate to accuracy.

Mexican Lt. Col. Jose Enrique De la Peña’s account is a significant focus, often cited as a primary source for Crockett’s execution. The authors respectfully acknowledge the historical significance of De la Peña’s stories, even noting that the specific details about Crockett and Travis were likely added later. They maintain a balanced perspective, not asserting that De la Peña himself wrote these accounts, which adds credibility to their analysis.

As I read the book, I tried to imagine what caused the diverging accounts, which began shortly after the battle. Is it possible that Mexican officers misidentified someone else as Crockett? The authors highlight the strategic advantage that Mexican General Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna would have enjoyed had he captured Crockett alive. Santa Anna would have known this and probably would not have ordered the former U.S. congressman executed, lending credence to the theory that Crockett died before Santa Anna arrived at the Alamo after the battle.

In fact, Santa Anna’s account – that he called in three witnesses who knew Crockett to identify his body – is the best evidence that De La Pena’s account was in error. The authors heavily weigh the accounts of these witnesses because they had personal interactions with Crockett.

In the latter half, the book presents a detailed forensic analysis, scrutinizing the evidence and witness accounts. I found the book convincing in its conclusion that Crockett likely died in front of the chapel, reflecting the original story told about the Alamo, albeit with a degree of uncertainty that any good investigation acknowledges.

Overall, the book’s balanced approach, detailed analysis, and respect for different perspectives make it a valuable contribution to understanding Davy Crockett’s final stand.

But the book goes beyond the technicalities of historical investigation. It breathes life into Crockett as a man of his time: a politician, a frontiersman, and a larger-than-life personality who stood for principles he held dear. The narrative evokes an emotional connection to the era and to Crockett himself, reminding readers why heroes like him resonate, even in an age often skeptical of heroism.

While the book’s detailed analysis may prove challenging for readers unfamiliar with forensic techniques, those who appreciate a methodical approach to history will find it rewarding. The authors’ dedication to uncovering the truth adds a fresh, thought-provoking dimension to one of America’s most iconic historical events.

For those willing to look beyond the myths, this book offers a nuanced, evidence-based portrait of Crockett and the Alamo — and, perhaps, a renewed appreciation for the fact and legend in the stories we tell about our past.